Human Rights Law

Home > History > Human Rights Law

| Copyright Dominique Clément / Clément Consulting

 

Human rights legislation was far from perfect, however. Discrimination against people with disabilities was not banned until the 1980s, and many provinces refused to recognize sexual orientation until the late 1990s. Whether or not Aboriginal people were adequately protected under human rights law was another complication. Under the federal Human Rights Act, Aboriginal people on reserves were not permitted to submit complaints, though they could, and did, submit complaints under provincial statutes for racial discrimination. Other deficiencies with human rights law were common across Canada. Fines were modest, often between $500 and $1,000. Only Quebec’s legislation recognized economic, social, and cultural rights. Quebec was also the only jurisdiction where commissioners were appointed directly by the National Assembly, which assured a greater degree of independence and job security. Other statutes empowered cabinet to appoint commissioners, and except in Quebec and federally, they held their positions at the discretion of the minister. Moreover, many of the first human rights laws included exemptions for charitable, philanthropic, or religious institutions, as well as major employers and service providers such as educational institutions. These exemptions later became the source of intense controversy. In Newfoundland, for instance, Christian churches monopolized the education system, and their refusal to hire people outside their faith or to allow non-Christians to be elected to local school boards clearly violated the spirit of the law. These exemptions also had a particular impact on women. Kimberly Nixon was refused permission to volunteer as a peer counsellor at Vancouver Rape Relief in 1995 because she was born male. The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal ruled that Rape Relief’s action constituted sex discrimination. But the BC Supreme Court overturned the tribunal’s decision and determined that the service was a legitimate exemption to the legislation.

Still, it is difficult to overstate the historical significance of human rights legislation. Human Rights Commissions were more efficient, faster, and accessible than the courts. They bore the cost of investigating and resolving conflicts. Human rights adjudication was also more accessible than the courts. Specially trained human rights officers investigated complaints, and the staff of Human Rights Commissions were drawn from academia, the media, social activists, churches, and the legal community. By incorporating existing legislation into a single statute, and developing experts in the field of human rights, the state accepted (to a degree) that discrimination was a systemic social problem. Significant resources were provided for most human rights adjudication, and each commission had a mandate to educate the public and to recommend future legislative reform to the government. Invariably, with a dedicated bureaucracy and a mandate to educate and promote human rights, the numbers of complaints would have a snowball effect, particularly as citizens became aware of the commission and would not face the financial hardships commonly associated with litigation.

A genuine rights revolution had occurred in Canadian law.

 

 

Complaints of Discrimination on the Basis of Race and Gender as Percentage of all Human Rights Complaints, 1976-1981. Complaints of Discrimination on the Basis of Race and Gender as Percentage of all Human Rights Complaints, 1976-1981  

Budgets for Human Rights Programs in Canada 1975-1983. Budgets for Human Rights Programs in Canada 1975-1983

 

Funding for All Provincial Human Rights Programs (combined), 1975-1983. Funding for All Provincial Human Rights Programs (combined), 1975-1983

 

 


The readings lists available on this site deal with a range of topics from human rights to biographies and specific events.


Human Rights Activism

Human Rights Activism

Documents relating to Canadian human rights and civil liberties...
Human Rights Law

Human Rights Law

Landmark court cases in Canada’s human rights history, including early hu...
October Crisis

October Crisis

Documents regarding the federal government’s use of the War M...
Gouzenko

Gouzenko

Documents relating to the defection of Igor Gouzenko, the RCMP...
Statutes and Declarations

Statutes and Declarations

Major federal and provincial human rights statutes and international...
Jewish Labour Committee

Jewish Labour Committee

Few social movement organizations can equal the impact of the...
Special Joint Committee on the Constitution

Special Joint Committee on the Constitution

The Special Joint Committee on the Constitution (1980-81) was...